In the rush of work, families, busyness, errands, many of us
have lost our paths through what Robert Bosnak calls "the wilderness" of our
lives.
But our dreams offer us a clear track to healing and
transformation, he writes in his new book, Tracks in the Wilderness of Dreaming.
A renowned Jungian analyst, Bosnak believes that dreams can
lead us from depression, disorientation and ennui to a feeling of aliveness and
vitalityif we take the time to work with them. Dreams are "the purest form of
creativity that I know of," says Bosnak. They're our closest connection to the
creative force of the universe. "By being strongly connected to your dreaming, I
think you can get much closer to the creative force that is driving you." Dream work
can give us deeper connections in our lives, more direction in our lives and more control
over our lives, he believes.
Bosnak wrote his first book more than 10 years ago, Little
Course in Dreams. He also is the author of Dreaming with an AIDs Patient, which
was produced as a play. He has a private practice specializing in dreamwork in Cambridge,
MA, and he trains analysts at the C.G. Jung Institute in Boston and in seminars abroad.
He spoke with Nexus publisher Ravi Dykema from our offices in
Boulder.
Nexus: You say in your book that we live in
our imaginations, but many people would argue with that. What do you mean?
RB: Its difficult to explain. But
lets assume that you remember your dreams. Then you would realize that while
youre dreaming, youre in a real environment, and that in this real
environment, events take place. This entire real environment is created by some kind of
human faculty which exists as pure creativity. Its a non-material reality, but
phenomenologically speaking it is just as real as material reality. It has space, it has
time, it has motion. Whatever experiences you have in your dreams are entirely real. The
problem is usually that most people forget most of their dreams and when they remember
their dreams, they remember them just as stories. They dont remember that while they
were dreaming, this environment was real.
If youre able to re-enter a dream, if youre able
to get back into the state of dreaming while being awake, you find that there are all
kinds of physical things happening to you while youre there. If youre able to
feel those again very deeply, then it is possible to access parts of your body that have
memories and pent-up emotions which you can release. Once you start doing that in
combination with working with dreams, you move back and forth between going into the dream
image, feeling what happens with your body, and moving back into the dream image. You
begin to create a great intensity of sensations. If you can do that for a certain period
of time, a transformation process begins to take place.
I probably should give an example. When, for instance, you
dream that you are in a room with somebody who is very angry with you, first you try to
lower your consciousness to a point as close as possible to sleep and dreaming, without
falling asleep. Then you begin to concentrate on the space as it was, the environment. By
doing that you begin to become aware of moods in the room, or feelings that you have
towards the person youre sitting with. That person becomes a real person again in
the sense of a real environment. Then you begin to observe that person very carefully, and
you begin to empathize with that person. Through very careful observation and empathy,
suddenly you can find yourself identified with that person. You begin to experience
something entirely different. You begin to experience anger, and the mood is very
different in that other person than it is in yourself in the dreaming. You get totally
different body sensations and a different experience of the dream. You start to move back
and forth between that person and the "I" in the dream, and when you start doing
that, moving back and forth between these two different people, you get two different
physical sensations and emotional sensations. The tension between those two will start to
increase and you become aware of all kinds of feelings that you previously were unaware
of, angers that are very deeply seated in your body, feelings of being attacked, all kinds
of experiences that are distributed between both these people in the dreaming. Slowly
youll find that you get very deep insights that are visceral, not just mental. Your
whole body knows that something is going on.
NEXUS: Do you mean you'll understand what
implications it has, or meaning, for your waking life?
RB: Not just that. It is more of a sense of
who you are, what your whole entire emotional life is like. We usually live in just a
small section of the entirety of our emotional life. Once you start working with dreams,
you can become aware of a much wider emotional reality than you were before, and that is
very helpful because, for instance, in the case of this angry person that you meet in a
room, if youre not aware of that anger, then your relationships are going to suffer,
because you will be projecting this anger onto people whom youre with and then
youll get angry with them, or you will make them angry with you.
NEXUS: Are you supposing that the anger you
encounter in your dream is likely a recurring theme in your life?
RB: Yes, because the strange thing is that theres a paradox going on. The
people in the dream that you meet are entirely real people. You experience them as
somebody else, not as a part of yourself. It is somebody else. Thats why Ive
developed this method of looking at the person as other, not as self, and of using your
whole aesthetic mind to observe, to get into the interiority of the other. The paradox is
that when you get into the interiority of the other, you begin to encounter elements of
your self. From the point of view of waking, all the elements of the dream are part of the
dreamer.
NEXUS: Theyre all created by you.
Nobody else is entering the deal.
RB: They are all created by the dreamer, but
the question of course is who is the dreamer? When Im sitting in a room with someone
else, it is not likely that I have created the dream because Im inside the room.
This man there has his own point of view that presents itself as an interior perspective
of that man. This man has his own consciousness, so there are already two carriers of
consciousness here. I didnt make that person, I didnt make this room. Now I
dont know who the dreamer is. I call it the dreaming genius, but I dont know
who it is. It is just a faculty of whatever it is that creates whole worlds that we find
ourselves in 20 years of our lives.
NEXUS: If you add up all of your dreaming
time, its 20 years of your life?
RB: The latest research indicates that it is
very likely that we dream six hours of every night if we have an eight-hour sleep. And
that would be about 20 years of our lives.
NEXUS: Tell us a few stories about societies
that consider dreaming as real, or at least vitally important?
RB: My book is very much about my trip to
the outback in Australia and conversations I had with an Aboriginal medicine man. In his
tribe, when they dream of a song or of a dance, they immediately have to teach it to the
tribe. The dreaming, according to aboriginal consciousness, has to do with the fact that
in the beginning, the world had no features. It was completely amorphous. The ancestors
from the dream time brought landscape into being from their dreaming events. So all
landscape is part of dreaming. When you have a dream with a song and a dance in it, it has
to be added to the dreaming to revitalize the world. So they see dreaming as very
important.
NEXUS: Can you think of a contrast between
our world and this aboriginal dream world, about how a person might view a marital
problem, the death of someone, a car breakdown, decisions, whatever?
RB: I told a dream of mine to an aboriginal
woman whos one of the leaders of that community. It was a dream that had my father
in it although he had died previously. She said "Well, maybe you have not fulfilled
the funeral rites. Maybe theres still something you have to do for the dead."
The notion is that if there were something left undone for the dead, it would make the
relationship between the living and the dead askew, which is a very dangerous thing. There
has to be harmony between the living and the dead, otherwise the dead will start
influencing the life of the living in a dangerous manner. The way I took it was in a
Western way, that there was still something that I had to work out in my relationship to
my father. I am a Westerner and I take dreams as being related to me, whereas she takes
dreams as she would take anything, as related to the tribe or as related to the
environment. If you take dreams as environments, as many traditional peoples do, then your
attitude toward the environment is the same attitude you have to dreams. Our attitude
towards environment is that its real estate: I "own" this piece of land.
We have the same attitude towards dreams: "This is my dream. It relates directly to
me." So my interpretation of the dream was very different from hers, although we came
to the same conclusion, namely that something still had to be done for the dead. She felt
that it was important that I still do funeral rites. Well, this book was the funeral rites
for my father.
NEXUS: In other cultures, are there techniques like
concentration exercises or breathing techniques or rituals that are used to aid in
retention of a dream?
RB: I have heard, for instance, of the
techniques of dream incubation.
NEXUS: What are those techniques?
RB: Well, in the olden days, especially in
Greece, you would sleep inside the temple and you would have a dream that would pertain to
your illness. The priest would help you work with it, and healing would come out of that.
From that we have developed techniques of dream incubation. If you want to incubate a
dream about a certain issue, then you visualize the most representative element of that
issue. For instance, if you want to incubate a dream about a problem that you have in your
marriage, then you take a very paradigmatic moment between you and your spouse and
visualize it very carefully. Feel it in your body, feel what youre feeling, try and
maybe enter the point of view of the spouse and feel it from his or her perspective, and
do what Ive just described about dreaming. In my experience maybe one in every 10
times you get a very clear response. It doesn't always work, but it works a few times. As
to breathing techniques, I know that, for instance, Tibetans, in their lucid dreaming
work, use a lot of breathing techniques. But I dont know enough about it. Ive
never seen it directly.
NEXUS: Can you give us some recommendations
about how we might remember our dreams? Any techniques?
RB: In the first place, if you want to begin
to remember your dreams, it is very important to realize that a dream may not necessarily
be a narrative. A dream can be any kind of image, and the narrative is usually much less
important than the images themselves. Value any image that comes to the surface. Many
people think that if they just had this little, little snippet, it is not worth
remembering, but everything is worth remembering if youre trying to start
remembering your dreams.
NEXUS: So youre saying value the
material in your dreams at the outset?
RB: Yes, value it and see to it that you
dont have preconceived ideas about what it should be. A dream does not necessarily
have to be an epic. Most dreams arent, in fact. Put a pencil and paper next to your
bed, or a tape recorder, and before you go to sleep, have the strong intention that
youre not going to remember any dreams. Its a kind of paradoxical intention.
Try to not remember any dreams for a week. Then, if any dreams slip through, you
dont write it down. You dont want to remember dreams. Be very adamant about
that to yourself. After that, if a dream pops through, begin to write it down in the
following manner. Try to not change your position upon waking. Stay as much in that
position as possible. Try to catch immediately one or two images, and really repeat them
to yourself so that they become language, so that you have it clear. Then write or speak
into the tape recorder. If you have a dream that you are sure you will remember,
dont be sure that you will remember it. Usually dreams that you think youll
remember for the rest of your life are gone within a half a minute. The best thing is to
write it down after you have learned it more or less by heart. Pay attention to the
slivers that you have remembered during the day. Tell it to yourself, or maybe tell it to
somebody else and ask that person to absolutely not interpret, but just to listen to the
dream. Youll find that the more attention you pay to dreams, the more dreams that
you will remember. Now some people, and there are many different theories why, have a hard
time remembering dreams. These exercises may not help, because for some reason some people
remember very few dreams, and it is not abnormal. Its just as normal to remember
dreams as to forget them. But if you really want to remember dreams, just keep on going
and at a certain point you will remember, at least a sliver. Then you can start
remembering more. But one shouldnt get ones hopes up too high.
NEXUS: What do we make of the dreams that we
do remember for weeks and months and years? Are they of some different type?
RB: Very often those dreams are of central
importance. You feel that they are essential to your life, that they somehow portray
something in your existence that is a crux of your existence.
NEXUS: So theyre even richer ones to
look into.
RB: Yes, definitely.
NEXUS: What about when I read my own diary
of a dream and have no memory of it?
RB: We all have stale dreams and fresh
dreams. And you can do different things with fresh dreams than you can do with stale
dreams, because if a dream is fresh then you can re-enter it and re-experience it. You can
move into other people in the dream. With stale dreams, you cant do that. The best
way to work with that, I find, is to work with series of dreams. Put a whole series of
those stale dreams next to each other, a chronological series, and read through them, and
see if there are themes that are similar. Begin to connect those themes. By working that
way, a lot of insights will begin to emerge. You will find essential themes in your life
coming back again and again in the dreaming. But dont try to do that immediately.
First, type them up and put all the pages next to each other. Read it through and as you
begin to become more and more conversant with the material, youll begin to see
"Ah, theres a table there and theres a table there. Oh, and those people
are sitting around the table here and these people are sitting around the table there and
these people coming back here." You begin to draw connections. After youve
drawn a lot of connections, you begin to look at them and youll find that they form
themes.
NEXUS: Where does this lead?
RB: You begin to inhabit a much larger part
of your being, and changes begin to take place, ways that youre stuck become
unstuck, and self-images begin to change. Your relationship to other people can change
because you have become aware that all these elements are part of your being. You no
longer have to project out so much. You can get in touch with people more easily because
projection puts up an invisible mirror between you and another, and you keep on looking in
the mirror instead of seeing other people. It can work very positively on relationships.
Since dreaming is the purest form of creativity that I know of, by being more strongly
connected to your dreaming, I think you can get much closer to the creative force that is
driving you.
NEXUS: And getting closer to the creative
force thats driving you would change you how?
RB: I think it makes you realize that life
has a significance beyond your own creation. Life has a significance beyond what you make
of it. There is a larger force that we are part of that creates a world in which we live
in our dreaming. You begin to realize that the same thing is going on in our waking
existence, that theres a super-ordinate being that you can call the Self, or God or
whatever. There is a larger faculty than just your conscious faculty that is steering your
life. You can become more a part of what is steering your life and you can get a much
better sense of direction.
I think much of the problem that people have is that they
feel very disoriented in their lives. And working with dreams can give you a very strong
sense of direction, to stay close to what matters in your life. I wouldnt want to be
living on the periphery of my life. I would want to be living as much to the center of my
life as I can. And I think working with dreams has helped me with that.